Okay - I know everybody loves it, I kind of like it also; although, until this season, I had never watched a complete episode. However, even before I actually watched it, there was absolutely no way I could avoid hearing about it. It is a big program, a huge hit, and especially good at drawing you in to find out what happens. Like a good book - drawing you in, turning the pages because you can’t wait to see happens next. Well, okay - NOT like a good book, not even close with all those commercials, but you get the idea here. The big problem I have with this program is that it is supposed to be a reality program. Reality meaning in my uneducated opinion, real. However, in actuality, the American Idol program is anything but real; in fact it is completely false. It is glitchy and theatrical, semi-believable, but mostly unreal, pretentious and affected. Phony to the bone, it is American Lie-dol and a big fat one at that.
Okay - now that I have presented what some may feel is an arrogant observation about American’s No.1 TV program, I guess I am going to have to back up my position. Here are three reasons for my belief that this program is an obvious ‘liar, liar, pants on fire’ type of program.
1. All contestants must possess some kind of ‘canned’ sound that the panel is looking for; a sound that is pretty solidly guaranteed to translate into mega- concert and recording bucks. And fast! A pre-determined sound will be exactly what the ‘judges’ are looking for and they will accomplish their self-fulfilling prophesies by continually cajoling and slyly limiting the genuinely talented youngsters who show up, by urging them to sing something ‘more for your age’, ‘what is on the radio’ and discouraging them from singing what they like to sing or what I (and I suspect others) might like to hear. The ‘panel’ wants homogenized talent, nothing too radical, not too theatrical; not overly showy and definitely not …and this is the worst of all not…not…’Broadway!’ Eeeuuuu, ugh, yuk. (But wait - what is wrong with Broadway…I just don’t get this part.) The lie? What the panel is really looking for has already been decided, no surprises, please, the sponsors and potential record-producers are already in the money-changing room caressing their soon-to-be-bankable cash, only because they adhere to a strict and unbendable formula. Do you really think that these people are interested in upsetting the apple cart by inserting reality into the mix?
2. Originality and inventiveness are discouraged, except during the audition, this little bit of unreality tricks the audience into believing that a ‘regular guy’ or ‘gal’ can win this so-called contest. While Paula and Randy may gush about the unbelievable talent of the frightened auditioned during the initial exposure; after the auditioned has ‘made it’ with a ticket to Hollywood, things quickly change and the ‘judges’ discourage any attempt to ‘sound’ too obviously different from any other mainstream performer who has made it big, or to sing something they simply enjoy singing.
3. “This is a serious competition,” Simon Cowell may say with a perfectly straight face, “and you should be aware that your performance tonight was incredibly mediocre and not up to the standards of this competition.” The lie? This program is really all about failing. Exactly twenty two of the original twenty-four will fail. This of course, not counting the hundreds who showed up to fail in the auditions, which some may believe is the most ‘real’ and ‘entertaining’ part of this program. Simon’s put-down is mostly contrived in order to produce what I call ‘cringe’ ratings, which is does quite admirably…in short, it is working. Cringe being what your face does while watching another suffer a remarkable and somehow unsettling insult.
In addition to the above, all contestants smile widely after being insulted. Is this possible? I wonder if you or I would smile that widely after being told we were mediocre - not good enough for this ‘important’ competition, not singing our best, not delivering, not connecting, and in fact, not even dressing correctly. But instead of being sad, there are more smiles and even more smiles while the camera pans to mom and dad who are both smiling bravely, while sobbing uncontrollably. More smiles while I am told I ‘rather stink’. You are asked why you had the sheer audacity to even show up and furthermore, who’s your daddy? Why are you here? No ticket to Hollywood for us! Still, there are dozens more tear-stained smiles until the camera finally and mercifully fades to the strange little man who explains that it is time for a commercial. (Is THAT his talent?} The lie? Smiles are for happy people, and these people are NOT happy - smiles or no smiles.
There existed at one time, variety shows and talent contests on television that were open and available to all contestants who applied and auditioned. Most made it on - even those with imperfections of hair, teeth, dress, and manicures, including the tongue-tied who were embarrassingly devoid of any poise or the ability to be completely relaxed while appearing on national TV. Ted Mack’s Amateur Hour comes to mind. Sunday evenings at about 7:00 PM, later Arthur Godfrey, and still later, a host of others. A parade of contestants would appear each week, some with extremely (by today’s standards) dubious talents, ready to perform for the American television audience. It wasn’t until the Gong Show that things got both warmed up and down and dirty and mean and nasty. Of course, this caught on! Americans discovered something new. It was fun to insult and ridicule people who didn’t measure up. Let’s have a little more of that!
A hog farmer from Idaho would play the spoons. That was his talent! By holding two spoons in each hand and clacking them against each other and then against various parts of his body while maintaining intricate rhythms, he managed to be both entertaining and real. When he was finished, and received the audience’s polite applause, he would smile. He may have had have gaps in his teeth large enough to drive a Mac truck through, but his smile, so full of holes, was genuine. It was real! It was not a lie. When the audience applauded, it was real because people were not rude and ill-behaved at least in a public forum. They hadn’t learned how to do that yet.
A housewife from Michigan would sing Puccini’s aria ‘o mio babbino caro’ from Puccini’s Madama Butterfly, a barber from Macon, Georgia would ride a unicycle while juggling three bowling pins and whistling “I Wish I Were in Dixie”. Twin brothers from Santa Monica, California would tap dance on a three foot square platform 15 feet in the air; an acrobat would twist herself into a spine-defying pretzel accompanied by background music from “Here to Eternity.” (Precursors to Cirque de Soleil?). After each act, polite and occasionally rambunctious applause would ensue. The contestants were happy; the audience was happy, genuinely happy, not faked at all. A group of young men would sing intricate four-part harmonies, and play their own musical instruments with virtuosic ability - saxophone, cornet, trombone and drums. No - wait - that was the Four Freshman, they were/are great! But they DID get their start during a variety show/contest in Detroit, Michigan.
Frank Sinatra appeared on the Ted Mack amateur hour and lost. This brings me by way of this rather torturous route to my main point. Like a buried seed contemplating the odds of bursting through a cement driveway, real talent will fight its way to the surface, breath the fresh air and defy all naysayers by blossoming prettily. Thank goodness, because here is my short list of those whom I believe would never have made it past the first audition on American Idol. What losses the world would suffer if Randy, Paula and Simon had been on the ‘panel’ to ‘judge’ these talents. Thank goodness these legends persisted, defied the odds and blossomed so prettily and for such a long, long, time.
Jimmy Durante (can’t carry a tune), Steve and Eydie Gorme (too married - not good for the single fans), Bobby Darin (those heart problems will keep him from realizing his full potential), Rosemary Clooney (too fat), Peggy Lee (sings too softly - no vocal acrobatics), The Four Aces (religious guys?), Judy Garland (Rainbows? You’ve got to be kidding me), Ethyl Merman (too Broadway), Joe Cocker (just too weird), The Rolling Stones (too raucous and noisy and nasty), Madonna (Like a Virgin? Yeah, Right!), Perry Como, Nat “King” Cole (too mellow), Sammy Davis Jr. (too versatile, unfocused), Elvis Presley (too sweet and unassuming, too shy, can only play four chords), the Beatles (too English, may compete with Simon Cowell, Les Paul and Mary Ford (not exciting enough) and finally, on my very short list, Luciano Pavorratti (don’t understand what he is singing about).
But the number one reason these people would not have made it on American Idol?
They were REAL! They were REAL and REALLY talented and they worked hard to get ahead. They worked their way up the ladder, they paid their dues, and they performed their hearts out. They made records and HOPED they would sell. Somebody took a chance on them. They brought us so much happiness and joy over many decades that a lot of you will recognize their names, even though you may not know what they did or when they did it. I wonder how many of the current ‘contestants’ will be remembered two, three decades from now? Real talent endures like nothing else. I am not suggesting that the competitors on American Idol do not have talent; in fact, many of them are extremely talented! But, to surrender their career prospects into the six hands of the American Idol Panel is tantamount to leaving it in the ham-fisted palms beer-guzzling couch potatoes or teens with cell phones. Oh, I forgot, that IS where the decision is left!
It is all a little scary.
Hey – it’s only my opinion and I’m the one with the Newsletter/BLOG. Please register and respond I would love to hear your thoughts on this or anything else you want to talk about.
Joy MacKinnon